I can't tell if Dollywood's blackout dates are a money grab or a means of trying to control crowds.
Either way, I am not sure that alienating your season pass holders (at any level) is the way to do it. I am of mind that it should be the opposite - a season pass holder only day during Christmas where there are specials all day, the food is automatically discounted and maybe special performances. I realize that SP holders get special perks now and the BAFs are nice and allow a friend to enter "free", but isn't that truly just a marketing ploy in the end? Invite a friend or two and hopefully it'll turn into a SP purchase in the future? Or invite a friend or two and they will spend "X" amount of dollars for food/merchandise?
As others have mentioned, I have been a SP holder for a long time and it saddens me to think that I am actually considering not getting one. I am sure, in the end, I will, but its a shame I am even thinking about it.
Ok, off my soapbox!
Looking forward to my Christmas visit in two weeks!