In the last twelve months, I have visited Branson three times and Pigeon Forge twice. What can I say, I'm a Herschend groupie apparently. Prior to that I had visited both in 2005.
There's a huge difference between the two areas now. Pigeon Forge is thriving, and feels alive in a way that Branson simply does not right now. Of course, Pigeon Forge benefits a great deal from its location, but in 2005 they seemed similar to one another and now there is a stark difference. As a 24 year old, here's my thought process:
1. Restaurants. Pigeon Forge and the surrounding area have tons of touristy places, sure, but there's a lot of food around, whether it's chain food or good independent places. In Branson, there seem to be fewer restaurants and options. Maybe there are more in downtown Branson but by the strip they're lacking. A few touristy places seems about it. There's hardly even a chain restaurant around. Every time I'm out of SDC it's a constant struggle to figure out where to eat.
2. I don't understand the demonization of beer and casinos going on in this thread. Some of you apparently think that either or both will automatically result in tons of drunks or neglect. I'm not much of a drinker, but in my experience that's not the case. I know several people who would be drawn to microbreweries churning out quality product. I like them too because even if I don't want a beverage, they usually have good food in my experience.
One casino does not mean the area will turn into Vegas.
3. It's amazing that a city as show-dependent as Branson doesn't have a headlining concert venue.
4. There's no main draw. Every tourist trap (I love Branson, but let's face it...) has one or one type of main attraction. Wisconsin Dells has waterparks, Orlando has Disney, Pigeon Forge has the Smokies...what does Branson have? SDC, nature, and a lot of shows that don't appeal much to the younger demographic. I don't know what this attraction would be, or even if one can be organically developed to the area, but there's no "hook." SDC is an amazing place, but I've had a hard time explaining to people what it's really about. Whereas I don't have to explain to them what Six Flags or Cedar Point is about. And if they're not interested in Silver Dollar City, or nature, or the shows, what is there to offer them? How do you get them to the area?